|
Citation
|
Judgment date
|
| January 2014 |
|
|
Appellate court upheld factual findings on status but set aside an unsupported $4,000 award and remitted quantum for reassessment.
Labour law – employment status and legitimate expectation – appellate restraint on factual findings – adequacy of reasons for quantum – remittal for fresh assessment.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Applicant awarded quantified salary and leave arrears after reinstatement; pension and medical aid claims dismissed for lack of entitlement or proof.
Labour law – quantification of damages after reinstatement; functus officio not applicable to ancillary relief – mitigation of loss – computation of salary and leave arrears – pension and medical aid arrears: entitlement and evidentiary requirements.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Non-renewal of a fixed-term contract was unfair where a ministerial directive created a legitimate expectation and a replacement was engaged.
Labour law – Fixed-term contracts – Non-renewal – Legitimate expectation arising from ministerial directive – s 12B(3)(b) Labour Act – Re-engagement and replacement – Remedy: reinstatement or damages.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Stay of execution granted pending appeal after balancing applicants’ prospects of success and potential prejudice.
Labour law — stay of execution pending appeal — prospects of success and prejudice — collective job action — s104(4) Labour Act — occupational hazard and lawful strike — reinstatement ordered by arbitrator.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Recommendations do not equal formal approval; dismissal for unauthorized study leave upheld.
Labour law – Absenteeism – Study leave – Requirement of formal Council approval – Recommendations versus approval – Legitimate expectation – Review of arbitral award.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
An arbitrator exceeded his mandate by ordering promotion and leave encashment; employer must cease withholding work and grant rotational leave.
Labour law — Unfair labour practice for employer to withhold work — Arbitrator’s remedial powers limited; promotion is employer’s prerogative — Rotational leave must be granted if denied but not encashed absent statutory or contractual provision (SI 390/1992).
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Appeals from arbitral awards are limited to questions of law, though grossly unreasonable factual findings and settlement representations may raise legal issues.
Labour law – Appeal from arbitral award – s 98(10) Labour Act – Appeal limited to questions of law; grossly unreasonable factual findings may constitute law issues – enforceability of conciliation representations/certificate of settlement.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Labour Court lacks jurisdiction to condone late noting of an appeal intended for the Works Council; application dismissed.
Labour Court jurisdiction – Condonation of late noting of appeal – Works Council appeals under Collective Bargaining Agreement – Statutory time limits for appeals – Court as creature of statute, lack of jurisdiction to condone appeals not before it.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
A generic collective title lacks legal personality to sue; proceedings struck off for improper citation.
Labour law and civil procedure — party capacity — generic/unincorporated collective citation — appeal determined on record — improper citation renders proceedings void — subsequent identification does not cure defect.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Dismissal upheld where employee’s communiqué misrepresented agreed overtime‑leave practice; disciplinary composition and procedure lawful.
Labour law – disciplinary procedure – composition of workplace disciplinary committee; interpretation of NEC Code (S.I. 31/2011) – chair vs management representatives; misrepresentation by worker about overtime/leave arrangements; requirement of mandate for worker representatives; procedural fairness in disciplinary fact‑finding; reasonableness of dismissal as penalty.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
The Labour Court dismissed an appeal for incomprehensible grounds raising factual issues and for relying on material not before the arbitrator.
Labour law — Appeal from arbitration — s98(10) Labour Act — appeal lies on point of law only; vague or incomprehensible grounds of appeal invalid; introduction at appeal of statutory instrument not placed before arbitrator objectionable; factual issues not entertainable on appeal.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Appeal dismissed as premature for failure to exhaust internal remedies following employer disciplinary proceedings.
Labour law — premature appeal — duty to exhaust internal/domestic remedies before approaching court — arbitration award complied with — disciplinary proceedings to be exhausted — reference to Zikiti v United Bottlers.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Labour Court may grant interim stay of arbitral awards pending review; lawyer's affidavit admissible where practitioner’s conduct is in issue.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
An appeal under s98(10) must raise a legal question or plead gross misdirection; mere factual re‑argument is not competent.
Labour law – Appeal from arbitral award – Section 98(10) Labour Act – Appeals lie only on points of law or gross misdirection on facts – Fixed‑term contracts and legitimate expectation – Factual re‑evaluation not permitted.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Arbitrator erred by quantifying damages without evidence; quantum set aside and matter remitted for proper quantification.
Labour law — unfair dismissal — reinstatement — meaning and effect — quantification of damages in lieu of reinstatement — requirement for evidentiary basis — jurisdiction (appeal v review) — contract formation (refusal to sign, suspensive condition, probation) — appellate review limited to points of law.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Unilateral appointment of disciplinary tribunal contrary to contractual arbitration clause rendered proceedings null; reinstatement or damages ordered.
Employment law — Disciplinary proceedings — Unilateral appointment of tribunal contrary to contractual arbitration clause — Non‑compliance with SI 15/2006 — Apparent bias and denial of documents — Proceedings null and void; remedial reinstatement or damages.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Failure to consult affected employees under s12C rendered the retrenchment and ministerial award void; reinstatement or damages ordered.
Labour law – Retrenchment – Statutory consultation under s12C(2) Labour Act – Requirement to consult affected employees or their representatives – Failure to hear employees breaches natural justice – Procedural defect renders retrenchment and ministerial award void – Reinstatement or damages ordered.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Dismissal upheld where employee ignored instruction, causing financial loss; splitting charges not prejudicial and penalty not an abuse of discretion.
Labour law – disciplinary proceedings – splitting of charges – conduct inconsistent with employment obligations – gross financial loss – employer’s discretion in imposing dismissal – appellate review limited to malice, bias or abuse of discretion.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Noting an appeal does not automatically suspend an arbitral award; party must seek interim relief under s92E(3).
Labour law – effect of noting an appeal on arbitral awards – s 92E(2) and s 92E(3) Labour Act – jurisdiction of arbitrator – quantification of damages – reinstatement and back pay.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Default judgment rescinded where applicant’s non-attendance was not wilful and appeal will be set down for hearing.
Labour law — rescission of default judgment — wilful default — service of notice and redirected mail — hearing appeal on merits — interests of justice.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
The respondent collective lacked legal personality, so the labour proceedings were improperly before the arbitrator and court.
Labour law – arbitration – legal capacity of claimant – unincorporated association/committee not a legal persona – inability of unnamed group to sue – procedural competency of arbitration – merits not reached where party lacks legal personality.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
An appeal does not suspend a retrenchment order; enforcement requires registration in the High Court or Magistrate.
Labour law — retrenchment orders — interim relief under s 92E(3) — noting an appeal does not automatically suspend a Ministerial order — enforcement requires registration with High Court or Magistrate — order must be sounding in money for registration.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
A fixed-term contract existed; premature termination was unlawful and entitled the respondent to two months' pay, not reinstatement.
Labour law – Fixed-term employment contract – Documentary evidence and misfiling – Unlawful early termination of renewable four-month term – Remedy: payment for unexpired term (two months).
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Condonation for a late appeal was granted due to reasonable explanation and prospects of success from employer's apparent waiver.
Labour law — condonation of late appeal — factors: extent of delay, reasonableness, prospects of success — employer's conduct may amount to waiver/condonation of misconduct; disciplinary procedure and applicable statutory instrument; prescription under Labour Relations Act.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Condonation refused due to unexplained delays and repeated non‑compliance with court rules.
Labour law – condonation for late noting of appeal – requirement to explain initial delay and delay in seeking condonation – procedural compliance – failure to file Heads of Argument – repeated non-compliance disentitles to relief (Musiyarira; Ganda).
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Appeal dismissed: unchallenged arbitral award fixing salary scale precluded re‑litigation of quantification.
Labour law — Appeal — Scope of appeal — Attempt to re-open unchallenged arbitral award via quantification appeal; Appeal on question of law — factual misdirection constituting law where decision is unreasonably perverse; Application of salary scale in quantification of terminal benefits.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
The appeal was dismissed because it raised factual disputes, not points of law required under section 98(10).
Labour law — Appeal from arbitration — Section 98(10) Labour Act — Appeals limited to points of law — Distinction between factual findings and questions of law — Mere assertion of legal error insufficient to convert factual complaints.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Application for condonation of an 11‑month late appeal dismissed for inordinate delay, unsatisfactory explanation, and no prospects of success.
Labour law – Condonation for late noting of appeal – factors: degree of non-compliance, explanation for delay, prospects of success – disciplinary hearing composition – appellate interference only for gross irregularities – forged medical certificates.
|
30 January 2014 |
|
Labour Court cannot stay an arbitral award after it has been registered as a High Court order; application dismissed.
Labour law – interim relief – stay of arbitral award – registration of arbitral award as High Court order – effect of registration on jurisdiction – Labour Court v High Court concurrent/pararell jurisdiction – execution/attachment of registered awards.
|
23 January 2014 |
|
Rescission denied where applicant's affidavit contradicted court record and displayed dishonesty.
Labour law – rescission of court order – striking off roll for non-appearance – applicant's affidavit contradicted court record – lack of candour defeats rescission.
|
16 January 2014 |
|
Whether the 30‑day period under s101(6) runs from suspension or from notification to the respondent to attend a disciplinary hearing.
Labour law – Interpretation of s101(6) – commencement of thirty‑day period – "notification" in s101(3)(e) means notice to attend disciplinary hearing, not suspension letter – jurisdiction of Labour Officer and arbitrator – premature referral invalid.
|
16 January 2014 |